博士论文网上评议申诉 博士论文盲审申诉复议结果大概多久能回来

下面是好好范文网小编收集整理的博士论文网上评议申诉 博士论文盲审申诉复议结果大概多久能回来，仅供参考，欢迎大家阅读！

Hello guys, I am PhD international student in one of the University in Zhengzhou, Henan.

And I faced this blind review situation.

My situation is: We submitted our thesis for blind review in march 2022, and result came out and 1A 3B, and one of the person give C, and he gives only format problems, and accepted all the other technical work. That we did not appeal and we agreed to the reviewer that o, yes we have some format problems in our thesis. We modified the comments of C reviewer and also we modified the othe minor comments from B reviewer. It took 5 months.

In Oct we again sent thesis to the same reviewer, and in november 2022 when result came out the again same reviewer gave C, and this time he found out new comments by totally ignoring his own comments. A research norm is when you sent the thesis to the same reviewer, he should have check that whether student modify thesis according to his comments or not. He totally ignored his own comments and give new and in the first blind review he said your work is all ok, only have problems in format and English. Now he said that problem is that your did not compare your model with recent approaches. Ok, fine we agreed that our thesis is not perfect but how can the same reviewer give new comments again for the 2nd time and give you C. So, can we say that he did not read thesis for the first time thoroughly?

My tutor think it is totally not acceptable, so we appealed to school, and it has been 14 days appeal result did not come out, i am nervous, shattered, devastated and that how come in 2nd blind review he again give C by totally ignoring his own comment! I wanted to suicide, i wanted to quit, but tutor gave me motivation and hope for good result of appeal! I want all if anyone feel same experience? I wrote message in English hope you all can translate and understand! I am in very mentally stressed situation...!

大家好，我是来自巴基斯坦的博士国际学生，在河南郑州的一所大学。

而我面对的是这种盲目审查的情况。

我的情况是：我们在 2022 年 3 月提交了论文进行盲审，结果出来了 1A 3B，其中一个人给了 C，他只给出了格式问题，并接受了所有其他技术工作。我们没有上诉，我们同意审稿人的意见，是的，我们的论文中有一些格式问题。我们修改了 C 审稿人的评论，也修改了 B 审稿人的小评论。花了5个月的时间。

10 月，我们再次将论文发送给同一位审稿人，2022 年 11 月，当结果出来时，同一位审稿人再次给出了 C，这次他完全忽略了自己的评论，发现了新的评论。

研究规范是当您将论文发送给同一审稿人时，他应该检查学生是否根据他的评论修改论文。他完全忽略了自己的评论并给出了新的评论，在第一次盲评中，他说你的工作都没问题，只是格式和英语有问题。现在他说问题在于你没有将你的模型与最近的方法进行比较。好吧，很好，我们同意我们的论文并不完美，但是同一个审稿人怎么能第二次再次给出新评论并给你C。那么，我们能说他不是第一次彻底阅读论文吗？

我的导师认为这是完全不能接受的，所以我们向学校上诉，已经14天上诉结果没有出来了，我很紧张，破碎，沮丧，为什么在第二次盲评中他再次给C完全无视自己的评论！我想自杀，我想退出，但导师给了我动力和希望，希望上诉的好结果！如果有人有同样的经历，我想要一切？希望大家能理解！我的精神压力很大...！